Wednesday, November 7, 2007

The Crucible, The Red Scare, and Other Witch Trials

1. What was Miller's point in writing The Crucible?





2. How are McCarthyism, the Red Scare, Arthur Miller and The Crucible interrelated?





3. Document other times in American history when 'witch hunts' were conducted and discuss the outcomes of the Salem witch hunt and the other witch hunts you find. What do they all have in common?





1. "Why I Wrote 'The Crucible'" by Arthur Miller

http://dialogic.blogspot.com/2005/09/arthur-miller-why-i-wrote-crucible.html




Arthur Miller wrote this article to discuss his motivation in writing the play. He goes on to discuss how the meaning of the play can be interperated in the modern society. Things have changed since the 1950's, but the message that Miller wanted to get across goes beyond the changes in society and America and is appicable to many new situations.


This is a good website to use if you want to understand what inspired Miller to write the play because he spells his thoughts and feelings in a first-hand account. The article is written by Miller because of the new rejuvination of the popularity because of the motion picture version (on which, Miller had a large artistic influence).


2. The Crucible- Tom Shafer


http://www.steppenwolf.org/backstage/article.aspx?id=164


This article is a background of the play for someone who is going to attend a performance of it. It gives and accurate and precise layout as to why Miller wrote it and the effects of Joseph McCarthy and the Red Scare on Miller's career and the writing of the play. The page continues to explain the relevance to problems today and challenges the audience to consider what Arthur Miller thought of being an American and what it meant to all of us.


This is a good article becuase it provides clear links from McCarthy and the Red Scare to Arthur Miller and the Crucible. It gives a prepatory question for the audience to think about as the witness the reproduction of the happenings in Salem.


3.Modern-Day Witchhunts

http://www.curriculumunits.com/crucible/whunts/huntable2.htm

During World War Two, the American government detained Japanese-Americans in internment camps under military guard. These people were American-born and educated, but their heritage called into question the placement of their loyalty; American or Japanese.

This, like most other witch hunts, started out as people trying to solve a "legitimate" problem by any means necessary. Unfortunately, this didn't always work and it infringed on the rights of American citizens. Most witch hunts start with honest intentions, but have devastating results.

30 comments:

Anonymous said...

Great sites especially the second one, but the hyperlink to the first one does not work. Check your rubric on how many posts you must do (I thing it is three). I would expect that you would you check yours and everyone else's periodically to read the comments and to add info as needed.

Anonymous said...

1. The website you listed for the first question does a good job in explaining what Miller's point was in writing The Crucible.

2.The second site was interesting because it talked about the play itself. It also explains McCarthyism, The Red Scare, and why Miller wrote the Crucible.

3. The website you listed for the third question was interesting because it explained how Japanese-Americans were detained during World War Two.

Beth said...

Your first site doesn't work. Your other sites were informative. I liked your descriptions of your sites.

Sonja said...

I couldn't look at the first one, but your description of the site was really good. The second site was very informational. The third site is a great form of witch hunting I never thought of that one. Nice Job.

Jarrid said...

1) very nice effort. you found an overall pretty good website to explain Miller's decisions
2) i liked the second site. it was the play layout...
3) very informative site Murph..i enjoyed reading over this one.

Ellen Gillette said...

1. I couldn't access your first website, but I'm impressed...your summary is longer than mine! Your comments make me want to see the site.
2. Great second site! I liked how it related more to today, and expressed some reflections from Arthur Miller himself that I have not come across yet. It gives a reasoning that I think is important for us to understand - about the fear, etc.
3. I used this website, too. It has so many examples and so much info. that there's no way that it's not useful to us for our projects. It is surprising how many witch hunts there have been and how many are still going on. Almost everything qualifies as a witch hunt when you think about it!
Good Job!

Lizzie said...

1.) Hmm, for some reason I couldn't get to your first site, but your summary is exactly on when you say that things have changed since the '50's, but the overall message of this piece of writing still carries over into current times, as I'm sure it will in the future.
2.) I've got a lot of good things to say about this site, but you wouldn't want to hear all about that, you read the site, but this is one of the best that I've seen.
3.) During WWII, it's sad the treatment the Japanese-Americans recieved during and after the war, especially when these witch hunts start off small and snowball into a huge, horrible event.

Randall said...

I couldn't get your first site to work, but you may want to list a description of the site and most likely find another site.

Kayla Jessen said...

Murphy... you have a very good description after all your sites. GOOD JOB!

Randall said...

nevermind about the description I didn't pay attention that it was below your site, good job.

Kayla Jessen said...

Your sites are really good, but you might want to add some more sites to each question. It might help you get more points for this assignment if you have two sites for each.

Randall said...

I have seen your site on witch hunts before. It is a valuable, informative site. I especially like this site.

Randall said...

Nice summaries and great sites. You did a great job.

Morgan Esser said...

1. Can't access your website.

2. Good site! It explained Miller's ideas which was helpful.

3. Interesting third site about the Japanese Americans. Never thought of that as an example.

Kayla Jessen said...

Good job Murphy! Keep working on it; you have really good sites that are extremely informative. Keep up the good work!

Jamie said...

1. Site doesn't open but I like your description of it-looks like a good site.

2. Great site, it explains everything perfectly...I had this site before too.

3. I like your witch hunt about the Japanese-Americans in WWII. Great job!

Your descriptions are amazing-good job.

Muffmack said...

I fixed the first website. I found the same article on a different site and hyperlinked that one instead. Enjoy!

Anonymous said...

i believe u did a great job explaining your sites and finding interesting ones. but it would be even better if you had a couple more sites to add even more info. umm...we both picked that the japanese were detained especially in california b/c they could've been spies, good job!

Ford Racer said...

1. Good first site.

2. I couldn't get into the second site.

3. I liked the third site. I didn't know that the Japanese were treated the way they were.

Anonymous said...

1. I liked your fisrt site. It was really informative. You summarized it great.
2. The site that talks about the play itself was interesting. It helped me understand the Red Scare and McCarthyism better. Great job.
3. Great job overall! You summarized each site in an understanding way that was easy to read and comprehend. Greatjob!

Anonymous said...

1. The first site is very informative since its what Miller wrote himself.
2. This second site is interesting on showing the relationship between McCarthyism, the Red Scare, and The Crucible.
3. This site is interesting since it even mentions The Crucible.

BUBBLES said...

1) He did so much research and knew about this stuff so much; sometimes I wonder if he felt like he was writing about his own life.
2) There isn’t much of an explanation on why the topics are related.
3) I didn’t know there were so many witch-hunts during WWII.

Landon Schade said...

1)Well you need to change the font for it is hard for me to read...it explains everything good though. Weird that he has a blog too?
2)This site is interesting and useful too i can use some of this information for future things.
3)I like your examples of 'witch hunts', they are different i guess you can say.

Anonymous said...

1. You have a good summary for this question.
2. This site was good for explaining about Miller's views.
3. Your site about the Japanese-Americans was informative and pretty cool to look at.

Anonymous said...

The first site was good. It explained why he wrote the crucible pretty well.

Anonymous said...

The second site was good. It was interesting because it talked about the play.

Anonymous said...

I like the idea of the japanenes being a witch hunt, but i think you were supposed to pick one that happened in the united states.

Lizzie said...

Your summarizing on your paragraphs are really good. It really made it easier to find what I was looking for when I went to the sites.

Anonymous said...

Good for people to know.

Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.c-online-casino.co.uk/]uk bonus casino[/url] coincide the latest [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com/]free casino[/url] autonomous no store bonus at the leading [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]casino online
[/url].